Returning Candidate?

Senior Subrogation Representative

Senior Subrogation Representative

Job ID 
# Positions 
Posted Date 
Position Type 
Full Time
Travel Percentage 
0 to 10%

Job Information


Be Here. Be Great. Working for a leader in the insurance industry means opportunity for you. Great American Insurance Group’s member companies are subsidiaries of American Financial Group, a Fortune 500 company. We combine a "small company" culture where your ideas will be heard with "big company" expertise to help you succeed. With over 30 specialty property and casualty operations and a variety of financial services, there are always opportunities here to learn and grow.


Great American's Trucking Division offers a nationwide program that specializes in insuring the unique exposure of the For Hire Trucker. This progressive program focuses on the owner operator and small fleet markets. We're proud to serve the long haul trucking industry with insurance products and services dedicated to the success of the Owner-Operator.


Great American's Trucking Division is currently searching for an experienced Senior Subrogation Claim Representative for our dedicated subrogation unit.  This unit reviews and pursues recovery opportunities on collision damages for our insured owner-operators, workers compensation claims for our fleet employee drivers and Occupational Accident claims.  Recovery is pursued from a variety of sources:  traditional subrogation from at fault parties through their insurer, state workers' compensation funds, reimbursement under coordination of benefits with major healthcare insurers, PIP carriers, medical pay provisions under commercial general liability, garage keepers coverage forms, pro-rata under “other coverage” provisions when multiple policies are in effect – to name a few.


  • Reviews and continues the pursuit of subrogation on a current case load.
  • Evaluates the legal liability on which to pursue recovery including the duty owed, breach of that duty, proximate cause and the damages in direct relation to the breach of the duty owed. 
  • Identifies and pursues avenues of recovery that may not have been investigated by the handling referring adjuster; directs the claims investigation when needed so that a proper foundation is laid on which to rule out or confirm the potential of recovery.
  • Takes the initiative when necessary to complete investigations.
  • Effectively communicates with policyholders, insurance adjusters, underwriters, attorneys and agents both in a timely and professional manner.
  • Establishes accurate recovery estimates based on the review of legal liability.
  • Maintains and controls the subrogation pursuit through collaboration with attorneys, vendors and insureds.
  • Writes effective contentions in Inter-Company Arbitration.
  • Ensures and processes loss expense payments and allocates recoveries in a timely and accurate manner.
  • Utilizes a diary system to pro-actively move claims toward recovery resolution.
  • Makes written recommendations for litigation, vendor utilization or for settlements above authority.
  • Other duties as assigned.


  • Ideal candidate will possess 6 months to 3 years of successful claims handling background, computers, and verbal and written communications, time management and organizational skills.
  • Bachelor’s Degree or equivalent experience.
  • Possess functional knowledge of insurance claim handling and must possess the competency of initiative.
  • Working knowledge and experience with a variety of claims systems or possess the ability to quickly learn and adapt to new claims systems.
  • We are looking for an energetic person who has a desire to learn, apply their knowledge and negotiate subrogation claim settlements. We are looking for an individual to work in harmony with existing team members and to provide a positive impact on our financial goals.Must obtain and maintain required adjuster licenses.
  • Complete at a minimum of 15 hours of continued education per year for adjuster licensing.
  • Professional development in obtaining the AIC, SCLA, or other insurance designations is highly recommended as an ongoing development tool.

Connect With Us!

Not ready to apply? Build your career profile here to connect with us!